Math Maker, Math Maker, Make Me New Math

3rd grade, and they’re doing algebra!  Asher doesn’t know it’s algebra, but I had to use an X and a Y to figure out the answers to his math homework.  And when I say X and Y, I am not only referring to two variables but also to:

X as in EX-cyussse me, but I am far from a vapid, mathphobic Barbie bubblehead, and I would appreciate a little EX-planation of this fakakta math before you spring some sort of new math on our kids leaving us homework tutors in a state of vengeful shock and rage while we drool over our pencils wondering what the fuck was wrong with the old math.

Y as in WHY the frigg did you have to go and reinvent the wheel?  Is there nothing we can salvage from one generation’s math to the next?  Seems that plenty of noteworthy people created and invented and solved a whole lotta shit with ye old math that we already hath.  You think you can do better with your new-fangled, fancy pants math?  Do you?!?  Huh??  Look at me when I’m talking to you!

Y as in WHY don’t you just park us on an ice float like old Inuits and send us out to the Arctic Sea to die with a pencil in one mitten and a math problem in the other?

Agloolik sets sail on a 220 square foot ice float that is melting at the rate of 4 inches per hour.  Pukik is launched on a 180 square foot ice float that is melting a rate of 3 inches every 2 hours.  Which Inuit will perish first?  Answer:  The Inuit who perishes first is the one who realizes that a world where everything old is unappreciated, undervalued and dismissed and chooses to use the pencil to stab him/herself to death before giving new mathematicians the satisfaction of solving the problem faster than he/she could have with old math.

Y as in WHY do you hate us?

My brother the math teacher tells me that creating new math is just a scheme to sell textbooks every year. When did math become some sort of snake oil sold off the back of a horse drawn carriage?  When did school superintendents start slamming back shots of Math Elixirs until they started to believe their own hallucinations of salvation, imagining that if they mounted a new math stallion, they could single-handedly rescue our country from continued global math humiliationElixer?  Then what does ‘e do with her?

Oh sure, you look real enticing, Singapore Math, with your impressive units and your bar models.  You’re all about simplicity and the pretty picture. Who could resist? Good on you for playing on our admiration for education throughout Asia. How many of us Amur-cuns learned about Singapore Math and thought to ourselves in the privacy of our own brains, “Must be good.  It’s Asian, ain’t it?”  Stereotypes aside, the fact is that we’d be far more likely to assume the excellence of Singapore Math than of Appalachia Math.

Singapore Math may in fact be the answer to our national math crisis, and my children may in fact excel in math as a result of learning it.  I, however, hate learning new things and feel compelled to kvetch about it here.  New math makes me feel old, and feeling old makes me cranky.

I am a 44 year old, flirting-with-frumpy housewife who has been thrown into a dressing room with a Miss Sixty wardrobe when all I want to do is wear jeans and a warm, soft jumper.  I’d shake my abacus at you, Mathenistas, but I’m afraid I’ll fall out of this off-the-shoulder, fluorescent tent of a blouse.  Now that I’ve gotten all that off my chest, it’s time to learn me some new math.

7 thoughts on “Math Maker, Math Maker, Make Me New Math

  1. Ha! I feel your pain. I couldn’t believe that A was doing algebra in 3rd grade either. I happen to love algebra, but at this pace they’ll be in calc by 5th grade and it will be all Sam’s responsibility then! 😉

    1. I always thought that one day we’d be able to take advantage of the fact that the boys’ uncle is a math teacher. I just never thought that day would be here already! Yikes!!

  2. Funniest post on math I’ve ever read! I was completely hopeless when it came to my daughter’s algebra homework….I had to send her to a REAL tutor. I suffered PTSD when looking at her worksheets — the horror, the horror. My worst subject ever, one that I always failed in and had to take summer school courses to make up. 4 hour-long 5 days a week class on Algebra. I think that’s when my nervous condition began.

    1. A cautionary tale, to be sure, Taradharma, and I’ve learned from your experience. Math causes a variety of side effects that may require professional help, medication and, in extreme cases, a tropical beach vacation – without children!

  3. Hi, I really love your website! I’m contacting you because I’ve written a book entitled Never Marry a Momma’s Boy: and 62 other men to avoid like the plague and I am hoping to get the word out about my new book! You can guess that this book is about types of men that women should steer clear of at all costs. It is a funny and smart read that I’m really proud of! If you would be interested, I would be thrilled to write a guest blog on your site. Please feel free to contact me at Thank you for your time!
    Susan Conner

  4. I am so with you on this Singapore Math thing. I went to a special night to learn how to do math this new fangled way and thought I had it until they demonstrated division and I was completely lost… I felt like I was back in 3rd grade struggling with long division.

  5. Deborah – I will add that Henry who is in 3rd Grade is being taught “strategies” for learning the multiplication tables. I beg him, please just memorize this shit – it’s so much easier! He won’t because that’s not “the way” they teach it now Mom! Holy Crap, he could be acing this stuff if they would get out of their way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *